Mar
16

My thoughts on the “Telephone” video.

normal_00274

It’s been a number of years since the whole world was talking about a music video clip as much as they have been GaGa’s “Telephone”. And whilst it may not exactly have anything on the superior “Bad Romance” video before it, it still offers up a whole lot more than almost any video clip being force-fed to us today, let alone the last few years.

We seem to be living in the age where music videos are an event once again, or, rather, and perhaps more specifically to the point, Lady GaGa’s videos are now an event. It’s something it seems everyone is interested in seeing; to the fans, the casual music listener, even the haters and people who listen to “real (boring) music”. The “real music” listeners watch it with gusto so they can bitch and moan later about how awful it and pop music is and why we should treat all pop stars like Hitler treated the Jews. In order to make such outlandish claims like this to match their super-tight black jeans and matching Libertines t-shirt, they’ve got to see the film clip so it looks like they have some kind of Indie leg to stand on during arguments with people like me about the video. At the end of the day though, they’ve sat down and watched that video clip, knowing full well they’re going to hate it. How long has it been since a pop star has been able to achieve that, and on a global level? You have to give GaGa kudos for that alone.

normal_00122

The near-10-minute epic extravaganza is, from the horses mouth, a social commentary on the American obsession with consumerism. But there’s some wild pop culture references sprinkled throughout too that are more than worthy of being mentioned. The use of Uma Thurman’s stolen ‘Pussy Wagon’ from Kill Bill was a direct loan to GaGa from Quentin Tarantino and drives the obvious mark Tarantino’s movies made on GaGa throughout the spliced-up-wonderment of “Telephone”, Beyonce’s nickname of “Honey Bee” also being a reference to “Honey Bunny” from Pulp Fiction, to the leopard-skin costume worn toward the end which seems to pay direct homage to the movies of John Waters and his cross-dressing star Divine.

The clip seems to have strum up some controversy, MTV have actually banned the video. Everything from the ‘lesbian’ kiss, a censored snapshot of GaGa’s Vadge and the death of an entire diner all playing a part. But that hasn’t stopped the drove of millions logging onto YouTube every day to watch it in high definition on their computers. The only thing MTV have really been relevant for in the last 5 years has – let’s face it – been “The Hills”, and the fact that they’ve banned the music video, in the digital age we live in now, means fuck-all what it used to back when artists NEEDED MTV to show their clips. It’s not detrimental any more and I find it funny how the media have, naturally, jumped all over the banning like it is of some actual relevance.

normal_00446

As for the video itself, obviously I really like it. The real surprise is just how much of a great actress Beyonce really is; she obviously follows instruction incredibly well – every scene she is in – absolute gold. This video has made her instantly more likeable to those of us who’ve perhaps been a little unimpressed by her output of late. She completely got it; there’s nothing that comes across as forced from her either which only adds to the charm of this video.

normal_00497

Kudos to Jonas Akerlund, the director, for doing such a stellar job too. There are moments, in particular when Beyonce is in a bedroom, alone, and GaGa in her jail cell, where the special effects and – to a point – even the placement of things around the room remind me very heavily of this Madonna video, also directed by Akerlund. Some might say you can’t teach an old dog new tricks, but I actually enjoyed seeing Beyonce’s head being twisted to-and-fro ala Madonna in “The Beast Within.”

normal_00075

Some criticism has been made that the clip has nothing to do with the actual song. And whilst I agree to a point that it’s a little disappointing, it’s certainly not as disappointing as it would have been had we been given some stock-standard boring video clip set in a nightclub. I’m falling asleep just thinking about it now.

It might be an over-the-top vanity affair here, but who cares? Why are we lashing out at Pop Stars – of all people – for being vain if this is the kind of final product we’re going to get from them? Maybe there’s a line blurred with the degree of Vanity GaGa puts forward in her work and the degree of vanity every other pop star puts forward that people just can’t quite differentiate between. Luckily for them, it doesn’t look like GaGa’s going anywhere anytime soon so, perhaps, they’ll get to see that line for themselves and finally get it.

Whether you love her or hate her, love the clip or despise it, chances are you’ve seen it in full by now, and you’ve probably seen it more than once too. Anyhow, why not watch it again?

Incredible.

11 comments
  1. My main issue with the video is that it is too stop/start and that when it is condensed down for, say, “Video Hits” (which, despite whether it should or shouldn’t be, it will) it’s going to be so weird and nonsensical. I wish it had been more like “Thriller” or “Bad” (to be cliched) and wrapped a story around the song instead of shoving the song into the clip and spreading it out over the 9.5 minutes.

    Beyonce is gold in this clip though, isn’t she? That bit that you’ve screencapped at the very top where she takes the bite out of whatever it is that she’s eating. Who knows why, but I love that bit. And “LET’S MAKE A SANDWICH”.

    I dunno…

    Glenn says...
    March 16th, 2010 at 3:40 pm
  2. Beyonce is fabulous here. Her stock went WAY up in my book after this collab. And the jury is still out on whether MTV US has banned the clip. They are saying now they have not, but the word did spread like mad that it was. Let’s face it, if this were 1989, it would have SO BEEN BANNED. I’m ready to crown her the Queen of videos, after Madonna’s own heart.

    Yuri says...
    March 17th, 2010 at 4:55 am
  3. Great review! I love the video – as you can tell by my own rant – and I’m dismayed by people hating for the sake of it. If team GaGa want to spend a fortune on an amazing 9 and a half minute video, shouldn’t we just be grateful that someone is finally going to some effort after years of videos that looked like they were slapped together for $10 by a TAFE student. It’s fantastic that someone’s taking the genre seriously again.

    And I know that I’m a complete Beyonce stan (so I’m not objective) but she brings so much to this by allowing herself to be swallowed whole by GaGa’s asthetic. I really, really hope the story will be continued. I want to see the sequel where they move to Brisbane and become soccer mums!

    Mike says...
    March 17th, 2010 at 11:44 am
  4. Ah the telephone video. it’s not really a music video is it, more of a mini movie. It’s bad girls meets cell block h (i’m surprised G’Gah didn’t crotch that mobile phone) via Kill Bill with outfits from Shania Twain, Kylie, Madonna, and most brilliantly the guy on the cover of Bound and Gagged magazine issue 60.

    Paul says...
    March 17th, 2010 at 7:12 pm
  5. This whole site is so Lady Gaga-lopsided. It’s hard to enjoy when she can seemingly do no wrong; you kind of get sick of it. This is the only Pop-forum available to me at school so it’s the one I use, but I’d love to see something other than you drooling over Gaga.

    The video was pretty sloppy and had nothing to do with the actual song. All she rally did was wear stupid outfits, trying to live up to the image that America has brought upon her.

    Jason says...
    March 18th, 2010 at 12:08 am
  6. nice review. I need to watch it several more times but for me — maybe the stop and start thing — it’s not as amazing as Paparazzi or Bad Romance (the latter is definitely her best, saith I)

    the cigarette glasses tho’…. I heart.

    March 18th, 2010 at 6:02 am
  7. Glenn: I do agree with you. Even as you’ve said it shouldn’t be shortened and edited for the likes of Video Hits, for example, it will be. There’s a fanmade edit that keeps with the running time of the actual song with no talky-bits that, although makes no sense, is quite spectacular. But I think that only works if you’ve seen it in full first…

    Yuri: Amen!

    Mike: I can’t remember when I last had to be at home at a certain time so I wouldn’t miss the launch of a new video clip. She’s changing the face of the way we look at things in the world of Pop. And Beysus was great!! I am totally coming around to her!

    Paul: I need a copy of that magazine then.

    Jason: To say that “this whole site” is Lady Gaga-lopsided is a bit of an exaggeration. I’ve written pieces about her TWICE this year, including the Telephone post, and the other being a rant about ticket scalpers. I kind of see what you’re saying but if one particular artist is making a bigger mark on me than most, why wouldn’t I be going nuts over them? It’s okay if you don’t enjoy the video the way I have, differing opinions are there for a reason. I’m not going to try argue your points in favour of the video because that’s all been done up in the article. Thanks for reading the blog Jason though and for your comment, I do appreciate it, and I’ll try not to spew about GaGa too much for you in the future.

    Adem says...
    March 18th, 2010 at 10:43 am
  8. Nathaniel: Bad Romance IS her best isn’t it?

    Adem says...
    March 18th, 2010 at 10:44 am
  9. i love it but oddly am not compelled to watch it over and over. it’s amazing but no “bad romance”.

    Will-W. says...
    March 23rd, 2010 at 1:32 am
  10. “Bad Romance” was a better video. While, its no “Thriller” it was a pretty solid video that was planned, stagged, and shot well. It was over the top but yet it was still sound. Where I felt “Papparazzi” failed to be anything but a self-induced ego trip, “Bad Romance” succeeded to be a perfect visual interpretation to the song. However, I doubt it was Lady Gaga’s mastery but the seasoned director’s. “Bad Romance” was definately the best video of 2009.

    “Telephone” on the other hand is a mess. Both Lady Gaga and the director went overload on the concept. The video was akin to a visual sugar rush or a pop overdose; empty of thought or reason but just an onsaught of sugary induced pop images. It doesn’t relate to the song at all; not even in a sly or subversive way. In fact the entire video completely undermines the song. The starting and stopping of the song to drive the WTF plot, disjointed it.

    At the end of the video, I couldn’t even remember the chorus, the melody, or even what the song was about. But oddly, I did remember the obsessive amount product placement.

    In a successful music video, the song is the headliner and the singer is the co-star. With this, it was as if the product placement was the real star, lady gaga & beyonce were doing cameos, and the song was just background muzik. Forget re-editing the video for Mtv consumption, edit the video into 15 – 30 sec chunks and run them as commmercials for the products that were featured. Then “Telephone” would be a somewhat avante guard piece on consumerism. But packaged as a music video its too shallow, too long, and too overwhelming for the viewer (unless they are hardcore lady gaga fans) to want to watch again.

    Lady Gaga please slow down. If you are indeed as talented and as edgy as you think you are, you’ll have a lifetime in the entertainment industry to prove it. Now it just seems as if you’re rushing aganist the clock before your 15 minutes of fame to run out.

    Molly Mou says...
    March 26th, 2010 at 11:45 pm
  11. check this out.. very interesting though it stinks of conspiracy theory :/
    http://vigilantcitizen.com/?p=3423

    LBOOGIE says...
    April 1st, 2010 at 1:00 pm
Add a comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security text shown in the picture. Click here to regenerate some new text.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word